circumlunar-transmissions/zine/issue001/solderpunk_whats-the-deal-w...

324 lines
21 KiB
Plaintext

- - - - - --------------------------------------------- - - - - -
C I R C U M L U N A R
T R A N S M I S S I O N S
- - - ------------------------------------------------------- - - -
Issue One May 2021
==============[ What's the Deal with Leap Seconds? ]===============
================[ A Brief Overview of Timescales ]=================
by solderpunk
ASTRONOMICAL SECONDS
Why is a second as didn't, so you're "why is a day as long
long as it is, and not stuck reading this, as it is?" - one day
a little shorter or a instead: a brief, is the time it takes
little longer? This incomplete, possibly the Earth to complete
is a seemingly simple slightly inaccurate a single revolution
question which leads overview based on my about its axis. And
down a deep and own characteristically since there are 60
delightfully twisted obsessive reading on seconds in a minute,
rabbit hole. It's the topic over the 60 minutes in an hour
something that I wish past week or so. and 24 hours in a day,
Neal Stephenson had a second is simply one
written an epically For most of the time 86,400th of the time
long, inexplicably that the concept of it takes the Earth to
compelling 1990s Wired the second has been rotate once. Or, if
article about, in the around, its length has you like, a second is
spirit of his "Mother been defined the time it takes for
Earth, Mother Board" implicitly by that of the Earth to rotate
or "In the Kingdom of the day. Everybody one 240th of a degree,
Mao Bell". But he knows the answer to out of the full 360.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
End of story, right? observatories tracking enough to notice
the movement of this). In fact, the
Well, no. This is a distant radio sources Earth's rotation is
perfectly sensible way across the sky as the slowing down. Very
to define time - for Earth rotates. This slowly, of course.
some applications, is easier than making Every century, a
it's the best way to precision measurements complete rotation
do it. This of the sun, but is takes about 2
astronomically still measuring the milliseconds longer
defined time scale is exact same thing. than it used to. The
still in use today in rate of slowing down
certain contexts. The EARTH IS A NICE PLACE is not steady. Some
official name of its TO LIVE, BUT IT'S NOT years the change is
modern incarnation is THE BEST CLOCK more and other years
Universal Time, or UT it's less. In fact,
(technically, there The problem with an even though the
are a few subtly astronomical overall trend is one
different variants, definition of the of slowing down, some
denoted UT0, UT1 and second is this: the years the rotation
UT2, but we'll gloss Earth doesn't actually actually speeds up.
over that here). The rotate at a perfectly The dynamics of the
official determination constant rate (it process are
of UT nowadays is wasn't until the 19th complicated, and we
based mostly on century that we could can't make accurate
measurements made at build clocks accurate long term forecasts.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Gravitational small, random was going to be late
interaction between fluctuations in their to lunch because of
the Earth and the moon duration over long the Earth's unsteady
is the primary driver, time spans. If you rotation. But by the
but the movement of define the second by 20th century, sci-
tectonic plates and looking into the entific and techno-
friction between skies, no two seconds logical progress
Earth's surface and are exactly the same. meant these tiny
its atmosphere and fluctuations started
oceans have their say, That's a pretty to matter, as we
too. The Indian Ocean inconvenient property began measuring
Earthquake in 2004 was for the official natural phenomena and
powerful enough to definition of a building machines
shorten the length of fundamentally which operated on
a day by 2.68 important unit like very small time
microseconds. There the second to have. scales. A 10 mega-
are even periodic For most of the time hertz radio
variations in the rate this definition was oscillator, for
of rotation that we used, the fluctuations example, has a period
just don't understand were smaller than we of 0.0000001 seconds
the cause of yet. But could reliably --only 100 nano-
the take home message measure. Certainly, seconds! Gigahertz
is that, whatever the they weren't enough to radiation, which is
causes, astronomical have an impact on important in radio
seconds actually have everyday life. Nobody astronomy and was
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
used for communi- Fortunately, in the The new atomic second
cations and radar 1950s, atomic clocks was defined such that
during WWII decades were invented which it had the same
before it came to kept time better than length as the
underpin modern any previous astronomical second
technology like GPS, mechanism. I'll gloss in use before it, as
WiFi, and mobile data right over the far as measurements
networks, has periods details, but suffice at the time could
measured in it to say, we came up tell, but it had the
*picoseconds*. Even with a new way to added bonus that the
very, very small define the second length of the second
variations in the which involved was then fixed and
length of a second are measuring the unchanging. Caesium
enough to make the properties of caesium atoms at a given
measured frequency of atoms instead of temperature "vibrate"
radio waves change, looking at things (very loosely
even if the *actual* moving through the speaking) at a
frequency is fixed. sky. In 1967, the frequency which, as
Modern technological relatively young far as we can tell,
society simply International System is completely and
couldn't be built (or SI, for the French perfectly stable, and
using a wobbly clock "Système which can be measured
like the Earth. International") of very accurately in a
units redefined the sufficiently advanced
ATOMIC SECONDS second on this basis. laboratory.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
With the arrival of until now is a little other hand, is
atomic seconds, a new less than 40 seconds, fundamentally
time scale was also but it will continue divorced from it.
defined: International to grow, without Thousands of years in
Atomic Time (or TAI, limit. And while the the future, there
for the French "Temps perfectly uniform will come a day when,
Atomique Inter- seconds of TAI make it according to TAI, the
national"). At mid- the perfect tool for sun rises in
night on January 1st some tasks, this drift Greenwich at
in 1958, TAI and UT apart from UT makes it midnight.
were perfectly problematic for
synchronised. Ever others. If you go This isn't just an
since then, they have outside at noon UT in abstract concern for
slowly but surely Greenwich, England (or the distant future.
drifted apart. The anywhere else at 0 In the late '50s when
seconds of TAI are of degrees longitude), TAI was defined, it
perfectly unchanging the sun will *always* was still common for
length (as measured by be high in the sky. ships at sea to
averaging hundreds of This is true today and figure out where they
atomic clocks all over it will be true in a were by using a
the world), but the thousand years, sextant to record the
seconds of UT Because UT is position of the sun
fluctuate with the fundamentally linked above the horizon at
Earth's rotation. The to the Earth's a certain time and
accumulated drift up rotation. TAI, on the consulting a printed
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
table of conversions. increasingly less International de
For this purpose, accurate as TAI l'Heure", but today
ships carried the most drifted further out of the torch has been
accurate clocks they synch with the Earth passed to a
could afford, and and the stars. This combination of the
compared them meant that the "new International Bureau
regularly against true and improved" TAI time of Weights and
UT time using time scale wasn't actually Measures, or BIPM,
signals broadcast by an improvement for for the French
radio stations all everybody. "Bureau International
over the world. des Poids et Mesures"
Celestial navigation COORDINATING CHAOS and the International
works very well when Instead of Earth Rotation
using a timescale broadcasting two Service, who have the
which is tightly different time signals gall to abbreviate
linked to Earth's for different the *English* version
rotation, and hence purposes, which could of their name and go
the position of things easily lead to by IERS) defined yet
in the sky. But if the confusion, on January another time scale,
radio time signals 1st in 1960 the powers in an attempt to
switched to that be (back then achieve the best of
broadcasting TAI that was the both worlds and make
instead of UT, International Time everybody happy.
celestial navigation Bureau, or BIH, for Enter Coordinated
would become the French "Bureau Universal Time, or
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
UTC - at last, allowing scientists technical
something normal and engineers around compromises, using
people have heard of! the world to ugly hacks. It cannot
calibrate their be any other way, as
The abbreviation UTC instruments and UTC is a stubborn
is a strange reliably measure time attempt to reconcile
compromise between intervals and two desirable but
the English frequencies very fundamentally
abbreviation CUT and precisely. But incompatible
the French whereas TAI is properties of a
abbreviation TUC (for destined to drift timescale: perfectly
"Temps Universel ever further away regular seconds, and
Coordonné"). This is from UT, to the synchronisation with
somewhat fitting, chagrin of sailors a spinning globe
because UTC itself is and astronomers, UTC whose rate of
a strange compromise is kept synchronised rotation is
time scale between UT closely enough with unpredictably
and TAI. Like TAI, UT that it allows irregular.
UTC is an atomic time seafarers to perform
scale. Every second celestial navigation The precise nature of
of UTC is exactly as with sufficient the ugly hack
long as any other, accuracy for safe underlying UTC has
using the SI standard ocean passage. This changed somewhat
second based on synchronisation is since it was first
caesium atoms, achieved, like all defined, but for
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
almost 50 years now, not absolutely fixed rather than removals.
starting in 1972, the at 86,400 by They don't happen on
ugly hack of choice definition. There a regular,
has been the leap almost always *are* predictable basis,
second. The way it 86,400 seconds in a like leap years
works is this. The UTC day, but 86,401 (which are an
difference between and 86,399 are also adjustment for the
UTC and UT - a allowed when fact that the time it
quantity denoted DUT necessary to keep the takes the Earth to
- is carefully time scale locked to orbit the sun once,
monitored. Any time the movement of the defining a year, is
it looks like that sun across the sky. not perfectly
difference is on divisible by the time
track to exceed 0.9 So far, there have it takes the Earth to
seconds, in either been 27 leap seconds rotate once, defining
direction, UTC is defined, although UTC a day). Because the
kicked back into and ATI are today Earth's rate of
alignment by either exactly 37 seconds rotation fluctuates
inserting or removing apart - the other 10 randomly, sometimes
a single second on seconds come from slowing down and
one particular day. hacks applied before sometimes speeding
This makes UTC the leap seconds were up, astronomers need
*only* time scale established in 1972. to be actively on the
where the number of All of them to date lookout for excessive
seconds in a day is have been insertions values of DUT. When
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
it's decided a leap precise time technology means that
second is needed - synchronisation celestial navigation
it's the IERS who should be caught by at sea is now rarely
makes that call - surprise when a leap a matter of life or
they are announced at second rolls around. death (although some
least six months in In practice, it's not sailors still
advance. They're always so simple. appreciate the
allowed to occur on relative simplicity
either June 30th or INCREASING of the technology it
December 31st, and IMPLEMENTATION BURDEN relies on), removing
are inserted or AND AN UNCERTAIN some of the argument
deleted at midnight FUTURE for making sure UTC
UTC (which is the stays in lock step
middle of the day in Leap seconds have with the Earth's
some time zones, of always had their rotation. At the same
course) on those critics, but at the time, the internet
days. At the time of time they were has come along: a
writing, the last adopted, their massive network of
leap second happened benefits arguably computers talking to
on December 31st, balanced their each other, with the
2016. In principle, associated hassle. 50 frequent need for
six months is enough years later, this hack activity on one to be
advance warning that is starting to show synchronised with
nobody doing anything its age. The advent of activity on another
which depends on cheap and reliable GPS (hence tools like the
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Network Time Protocol, added to software as Some systems, of
NTP). Computer an afterthought - if course, forget to do
programmers *hate* they are added at all. anything at all.
leap seconds, for the Some systems represent Because all the leap
same reason they hate the extra second using seconds to date have
Daylight Saving Time: the timestamp been insertions
they complicate time 23:59:60, but others rather than removals,
calculations (you instead repeat the it's a safe bet that
can't accurately timestamp 23:59:59 there's plenty of
calculate the number twice (since some software out there
of seconds between two software will fail to which has worked
UTC timestamps without parse a timestamp correctly so far but
consulting a table of ending in :60). Other will fail the first
when previous leap systems "smear" the time a second is
seconds were inserted) leap second out over removed. And the
and are a frequent longer time periods, Earth's rotation is
cause of confusion and like 24 hours, to going through a bit
errors, when one avoid problems of a fast phase right
system implements them associated with sudden now, so the first
differently from discontinuities. This negative leap second
another its trying to just leads to a whole might be looming on
interoperate with. day of small, slowly the horizon.
varying errors
Affordances for leap compared to The software
seconds are often non-smearing systems. interoperability
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
situation at the time option. It's one thing cause are only likely
of a leap second is to shut down the New to get worse. The
bad enough that York Stock Exchange atomic definition of
several major stock for an hour, but Air second likely isn't
exchanges simply Traffic Control has to going away any time
agreed to voluntarily stay up 24/7. It's no soon, though, and
shut down for an hour surprise that that means that
around midnight UTC in increasingly many getting rid of leap
2016, rather than risk voices in the tech seconds entirely
problems by continuing industry are calling means abandoning the
to trade during the for leap seconds to be millennia old notion
leap second. Given abolished. Plenty of that the way we
that a number of major people are very represent time is
web services, unhappy with that intimately linked
including Amazon, idea, of course, not with the natural
Instagram, Netflix and to mention there's no cycle of night and
Twitter, experienced consensus on what to day. Assuming we're
outages around this do instead. not willing to do
time, this was that, there are only
probably not a bad It's far from clear two alternatives:
idea. Of course, what the future holds coming up with a new
simply shutting time for the leap second. ugly hack which is
critical services off As software continues somehow less
for every leap second to eat the world, the problematic, or
isn't always an headaches leap seconds giving up on a "one
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
size fits all" time recommend the article time scales like
scale. "The leap second: its Ephemeris Time (ET),
history and possible GPS Time (GPST) and
BUT WAIT, future", which you can Terrestrial Time
THERE'S MORE! easily find on the web (TT), and discover
(full citation below), that the SI system of
If you think this along with, as always, units defined the
story has been following Wikipedia second based on
needlessly fiddly and links wherever they something other than
complicated, rest take you. Along the Earth's rotation when
assured I have skipped way you can learn the it was established in
over a tonne of difference between 1960, seven years
details. If you're UT0, UT1 and UT2, meet before the caesium
actually interested to other exciting definition was
learn more, I highly astronomic and atomic adopted.
- - -[ REFERENCES ]- - -
Nelson, R., McCarthy, D., Malys, S., Levine, J.M., Guinot, B.,
Fliegel, H., Beard, R., & Bartholomew, T. (2001). The Leap Second
- Its History and Possible Future. Metrologia, 38, 509-529.
"Time-nuttery 101" by Ole Petter Ronningen
https://efos3.com/TimeNut.html
"UTC might be redefined without Leap Seconds" by Steve Allen
https://ucolick.org/~sla/leapsecs/timescales.html
- - - ------------------------------------------------------- - - -
- - - - - --------------------------------------------- - - - - -